Why are fanatics obsessed with women’s bodies?
By Alaa el-Aswany
20 oct 2009
The Shabaab movement in Somalia controls large parts of the south and centre of the country, and
because officials in this movement embrace the Wahabi ideology they have imposed their views on
Somalis by force and have issued strict decrees banning films, plays, dancing at weddings, football
matches and all forms of music, even the ring tones on mobile phones. Some days ago these
extremists carried out a strange operation: they arrested a Somali woman and whipped her in public
because she was wearing a bra. They announced clearly that wearing these bras was unIslamic
because it is a form of fraud and deception. We may well ask what wearing bras has to do with
religion, why they would consider them to be a form of fraud and deception, and how they managed
to arrest the woman wearing the bra when all Somali women go around with their bodies
completely covered. Did they appoint a special female officer to inspect the breasts of women
passing by in the street? One Somali woman called Halima told Reuters news agency: "Al Shabaab
forced us to wear their type of veil and now they order us to shake our breasts…They first banned
the former veil and introduced a hard fabric which stands stiffly on women’s chests. They are now
saying that breasts should be firm naturally, or just flat."
In fact this excessive interest in covering up women’s bodies is not confined to the extremists in
Somalia. In Sudan the police examine women’s clothing with extreme vigilance and arrest any
woman who is wearing trousers. They force her to make a public apology for what she has done and
then they whip her in public as an example to other women. Some weeks ago Sudanese journalist
Lubna al-Husseini insisted on wearing trousers and refused to make the public apology. When she
refused to submit to flogging she was referred to a real trial and the farce reached its climax when
the judge summoned three witnesses and asked them if they had been able to detect the shape of the
accused’s underwear when she was wearing the trousers. When one of the witnesses hesitated in
answering, the judge asked him directly: “Did you see Lubna’s stomach when she was wearing the
trousers?” The witness replied: “To some extent.” Lubna said she was wearing a modest pair of
trousers and that the scandalous pair she was accused of wearing would not suit her at all because
she is plump and would need to lose 20 kilos in order to put them on. But the judge convicted her
anyway and fined her 500 pounds or a month in prison.
In Egypt too, extremists continue to take an excessive interest in women’s bodies and tin rying to
cover them up entirely. They not only advocate that women wear the niqab but also that they wear
gloves on their hands, which they believe will ensure that no passions are aroused when men and
women shake hands. We really do face a phenomenon which deserves consideration: why are
extremists so obsessed with women’s bodies? Some ideas might help us answer this question:
Firstly, the extremist view of women is that they are only bodies and instruments for either
legitimate pleasure or temptation, as well as factories for producing children. This view strips
women of their human nature. Accusing the Somali woman of fraud and deception because she was
wearing a bra is the same charge of commercial fraud which the law holds against a merchant who
conceals the defects of his goods and make false claims about their qualities in order to sell them at
a higher price. The idea here is that a woman who accentuate her breasts by using a bra gives a false
impression of the goods (her body), which is seen as fraud and deception of the buyer (the man)
who might buy (marry) her for her ample breasts and later discover that they were ample because of
the bra and not by nature. It would be fair to remember that treating women’s bodies as
commodities is not something found only in extremist ideologies but often happens in Western
المزيد